Hello dear
Welcome to Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA
Arcaro and Genell, located at 443 S Main St in Old Forge, PA, is a cherished gem renowned for its Old Forge-style pizza. With a legacy that spans decades, this family-run establishment captivates locals and visitors alike with its fresh dough, rich toppings, and distinctive crispy crust. Customers rave about the delicious flavor and friendly service, with many noting the restaurant's welcoming atmosphere. Whether it's a quick slice during lunch or catering for special occasions, Arcaro and Genell consistently delivers quality and warmth. A must-visit for pizza lovers, it's a place where unforgettable flavors meet heartfelt hospitality.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
6 Cut Red
Linguini Carbonara
Fettucine With Shrimp
Fettucine With Chicken
About
Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA
Located in the heart of Old Forge, Pennsylvania, Arcaro and Genell has established itself as a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts and food lovers alike. With a storied history in the pizza scene, this family-run establishment at 443 S Main St has cultivated a loyal following thanks to its exceptional offerings and warm ambiance.
What sets Arcaro and Genell apart is its dedication to crafting the quintessential Old Forge-style pizza. Customers rave about the excellent customer service and the friendly staff, as evidenced by John Thein's experience, where he noted the delightful flavor of the pizza he sampled for a client. It's not just about the food here; it's about the community connection that the owners foster, ensuring that every patron feels like family.
Reviewers consistently highlight the freshness of the ingredients, with Rashaad Ishmael praising the pizza for its fresh dough and toppings, delivering a vibrant flavor in every bite. The crispy crust, praised by Rob A, strikes the perfect balance between satisfying crunch and delicious chewiness, making it an ideal vessel for the rich sauce and creamy cheese blend. It's this commitment to quality that has turned casual visitors into regulars, with many promising to return for more.
Beyond pizza, Arcaro and Genell is celebrated for its ability to cater events, as noted by Stacie T, who marveled at the excellent service during a work Christmas party. The beautifully decorated banquet room adds to the charm, making it a fantastic venue for gatherings of all kinds.
But perhaps the most heartfelt testament comes from Walter Graham, who fondly remembers when his child enjoyed white pizza from Arcaro and Genell for the first time. Such nostalgic moments speak volumes about the impact this establishment has had on the community over the years.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Arcaro and Genell promises an unforgettable meal coupled with an unparalleled sense of hospitality. The next time you find yourself in Old Forge, be sure to stop by and savor a slice of nostalgia and quality that you won’t soon forget.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I went to pick up pizza and tripe there for my client who said it was their favorite pizza place. Customer service was great. My client offered me the pizza and I had a piece. That was delicious. I would definitely recommend to my friends and others. ”
“ In town for new job and found this small shop that had the rumored “best old forge style pizza” So I decided to try it out. Ordered online and my order was just about ready once I got there. Staff is super friendly and treat you with the upmost respect. I got the pizza back to my hotel and it was very good! Fresh dough, and fresh toppings. Everything tasted up to par. Only thing (and I’m not deducting anything because this is my own preference) is I wish it had some type of butter or garlic butter on the crust. Nevertheless, flavor was present and I loved every bite of my pizza. If you’re a local or just passing thru and want to try some good pizza in the area, Arcaro and Genell is the place to go! best of wishes to the company ”
“ Stopped in here for a couple slices at lunch in the recommendation of a friend. Had to try Old Forge pizza when I was out this way in Pennsylvania. I enjoyed it - kind of in between grandma and Sicilian style slices. Nice crispy crust, good sauce and flavorful cheese blend. Will be back! The owner knew everyone by first name who came in to pick up their lunch orders. A true gem. ”
“ Lisa was a dream to work with for our work Christmas Party! The food was great, the bartenders and servers friendly, and the banquet room was decorated beautifully - lived that there were tables for photo props including a small standing height table which was perfect for me checking people in as they arrived! Thank you! ”
“ First solid food my kid ever had was white pizza from here when I was working in the area and her mom brought her by to see me. Afterwards, we always made it a stop when we were in the area. 40 years later I stopped by on Easter after a funeral in Rochester. Mike was gracious enough to heat us up a half tray of double crust white to go. Still amazing Pizza! Like no other. You gotta stop here. ”
“ This was my first experience trying Old Forge style pizza. It was by far the best pizza you can make! So buttery and crispy with a great tasting sauce. The prices are super reasonable, fast service. Overall a great experience and I wish I could eat it every day! ”
“ Pizza trail brought us here. Everything was absolutely perfect and delicious! They make fresh cannolis on request, just ask, the sign says so! Gluten-free ravioli too!! The pictures don't do it justice. We heated everything up when we got home and it smells just like when we picked it up. They have their own parking lot for "take aways", which is on the corner. Small parking lot but its literally all you need. They have music outside playing with chairs and table, so I'm sure its so inviting in the warmer months! Will be return customers when back in the area!! ”
“ Our favorite of The Old Forge pizza restaurants. They only do “takeaway”. The white is perfect and the red is also delicious. Could not be nicer servers. They have a bocce court and also a rental hall. At the “takeaway” store they offer a variety of Italian cuisine specialties. ”